Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Vitalik Buterin says crypto regulations have created ‘anarcho-tyranny’

Validated Media

Ethereum’s outspoken co-founder, Vitalik Buterin, recently expressed his frustration over the current state of cryptocurrency regulation and offered up a surefire solution to the problem.

Responding to a user on Warpcast, a social media platform built on the Farcaster protocol, Buterin described a situation where current regulatory efforts have essentially painted good-faith cryptocurrency developers into a corner:

  Source: Vitalik Buterin

“The main challenge with crypto regulation (esp in the US) has always been this phenomenon where if you do something useless, or something where you're asking people to give you money in exchange for vague references to potential returns at best, you are free and clear, but if you try to give your customers a clear story of where returns come from, and promises about what rights they have, then you're screwed because you're "a security". The incentive gradient that this "anarcho-tyranny" creates ends up worse for the space than either plain anarchy or plain tyranny.”

Anarchy

On the anarchy side of things, there appears to be no end to the glut of bad actors, scammers, and baseless hypesters proliferating on social media and sharing platforms.

Buterin previously conjured three recommendations purported to be able to solve the problem of “useless” cryptocurrency products and services.

  Description: Screenshot of a post from Vitalik Buterin. Source: “Jason.”  

These recommendations include limiting leverage, requiring audits and transparency, and gating usage with knowledge tests.

While it’s unclear how cryptocurrency knowledge tests could be implemented at a regulatory level or administered at the individual or corporate level, it would likely be a matter of policy to place limits on cryptocurrency project leverage and institute auditing and transparency reporting requirements.

Tyranny

Unfortunately, the cryptocurrency community's sentiment seems to be that the U.S. has both an outsized number of cryptocurrency users and an approach to cryptocurrency regulation that could best be described as nebulous or uneven.

Buterin says that rather than offer the most protections to companies and projects without a long-term vision or plan, he would “much rather see us move to the opposite situation, where issuing a token without giving a clear long-term story for why it will maintain or increase in economic value is the riskier thing.”

However, Buterin also alluded that implementing regulations that serve the cryptocurrency industry is only part of the battle:

"Actually getting to this will require good-faith engagement, both from regulators and from industry.”

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Shared sequencer network Astria receives $12.5 million in strategic financing

    The shared sorter network Astria announced the completion of a $12.5 million financing round, led by dba and Placeholder VC, with participation from RockawayX, Maven11, 1kx, Bankless Ventures, Figment Capital and Batu, as well as angel investors Yuki, DCBuilder, Hasu, Will Price and Jason Yanowitz. These funds will be used to continue building the Astria sorting layer and Astria Stack, allowing anyone to deploy permissionless aggregation without relying on centralized sorters.

  • Cointime June 30th News Express

    1.13,300 ETH transferred to Coinbase International 2.A whale withdrew 3 million OM from Binance 6 hours ago 3.Kingsway Capital: Its largest token holding so far is TON4.Solana on-chain DEX had a trading volume of $1.148 billion yesterday 5.Data: Taiko mainnet has 24.89 million transactions in the first month, with a total of about 710,000 independent wallets 6.Jupiter Lianchuang: PPP Meme coin experiment has been completed and analysis of participants has started7.Amber Group and Bitpanda deposit AGIX and OCEAN to Binance 8.In the past 7 days, the transaction volume of NFT on Polygon chain increased by 33.71% month-on-month9.Arkham: Vitalik's total ETH holdings are worth more than $800 million 10.A whale redeemed 1986 ezETH from Renzo and transferred it to Binance

  • Cointime June 29th News Express

    1. In the past 24 hours, the transaction volume of Pudgy Penguins was nearly 2 million US dollars, an increase of nearly 700%

  • Symbiolic, the top individual staker, has invested $41.62 million worth of ETH in the liquidity staking and re-staking protocols.

    A certain whale has cumulatively invested $41.62 million worth of ETH into various liquidity pledge/re-pledge agreements, as monitored by on-chain analyst @ai_9684xtpa. The whale is currently ranked as the top personal pledge holder for Symbiolic, with investment details as follows:

  • The US SEC has returned the S-1 form to the potential Ethereum ETF issuer with a few comments, asking it to fix the problem and resubmit.

    The US Securities and Exchange Commission has returned the S-1 form to the potential Ethereum ETF issuer with some comments, asking them to address the issues and resubmit. Sources say that at least one more round of review is needed before these measures can take effect. The issuer has reportedly been asked to address these comments and resubmit before July 8th. Sources note that this will not be the final declaration after the form is returned, meaning that at least one more declaration is needed before the ETF can begin trading.

  • Coinbase Chief Legal Officer: US SEC blocks Coinbase’s request to disclose Gary Gensler’s communication documents

    Paul Grewal.eth, the Chief Legal Officer of Coinbase, wrote on the X platform that the issues of Chevron and Binance's secondary sales have been clarified, but in Coinbase's lawsuit, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has prevented Coinbase from requesting the disclosure of Gary Gensler's communication documents. In March 2021, Gary Gensler told the U.S. Congress that the SEC lacked regulatory authority over digital asset exchanges, confirming the long-held belief among market participants that digital asset trading on these exchanges is not within the jurisdiction of securities law. Coinbase has requested that Gary Gensler provide documents related to these communications because they are related to how the SEC's enforcement actions violate the due process requirements of the Constitution, but the SEC and Gary Gensler are trying to prevent the disclosure of these documents.

  • Wormhole: A new contract “SolanaWorldIDProgram” will be developed to support the expansion of World ID to the Solana network

    Worldcoin has announced that it has expanded its World ID to the Solana network through Wormhole. The main goal of this integration is to enable protocols on Solana to verify user World IDs that have already been authenticated on Ethereum. According to Wormhole, a new smart contract called SolanaWorldIDProgram will be developed on Solana, which will be responsible for verifying and storing the World ID state root and verifying inclusion proofs. SolanaWorldIDProgram and the Wormhole State Bridge Service from Ethereum to Solana provide a powerful and scalable cross-chain identity verification solution.

  • Supreme Court: "A Token" network platform collected more than 9 million virtual currencies such as Bitcoin, Tether, and EOS from members

    The Supreme People's Court and the State Administration for Market Regulation jointly issued five typical cases of punishing pyramid schemes on the Internet in accordance with the law. Some of them falsely promised high returns by investing in "virtual currencies". The defendants, including Chen, used blockchain as a gimmick to plan the establishment of the "Token" network platform. According to statistics, the platform has registered more than 2.6 million member accounts, with a hierarchy of 3,293 levels, and collected more than 9 million virtual currencies such as Bitcoin, Tether, and EOS. The people's court sentenced the organizers and leaders of cross-border network pyramid schemes according to their positions and roles in the entire criminal chain, and confiscated virtual currencies such as Bitcoin involved in the case in accordance with the law. Relevant officials of the Supreme People's Court stated that in the next step, the people's court will work with market supervision departments and other units to strictly punish illegal pyramid schemes on the Internet in accordance with the law.

  • MarbleX and Netmarble Launch $20 Million Ecosystem Promotion Plan

    Ethereum game platform Immutable has announced a partnership with the blockchain game division Marblex of South Korean gaming giant Netmarble. The collaboration will migrate Marblex's ecosystem and its multiple games from the Klaytn blockchain to the Ethereum Layer 2 network Immutable zkEVM. The games include "Ni no Kuni: Cross Worlds", "A3: Still Alive" and "Meta World: My City", and the two parties will also launch an "ecosystem promotion plan" to provide up to $20 million in support to developers to attract new games to join Marblex and Immutable. It is currently unclear whether the Immutable migration will affect Saga's plans, and the project representatives have not commented on the issue.

  • Vitalik Buterin: ZK-SNARKs and other technologies are inefficient, and Ethereum aims to achieve real-time proofs

    Vitalik Buterin, the founder of Ethereum, gave a keynote speech titled "Reaching the Limits of Protocol Design" at the 2024 Hong Kong Web3 Carnival. Vitalik Buterin stated that technologies such as ZK-SNARKs, MPC, and FHE have efficiency and security issues. Ethereum's slot block time is 12 seconds, the average block verification time is about 400 milliseconds, and the ZK-SNARK proof time is about 20 minutes. Ethereum's goal is to achieve real-time proof. Regarding the current low efficiency issue, Vitalik stated that the solution is "parallelization and aggregation trees", using SNARK algos and hash to improve efficiency, and using ASIC for ZK hardware acceleration.