Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Protecting Privacy in the Metaverse

Validated Individual Expert
Image generated by Rosenberg using Midjourney

Virtual and augmented reality are deeply humanizing technologies, empowering users to experience digital content in the most natural form possible. At the same time, there are major privacy concerns, as metaverse platforms could easily track and profile users at levels that go far beyond any current consumer technologies.

So what can we do to protect our privacy in the metaverse?

The image below shows me standing in a “Virtual Escape Room” created by researchers at U.C. Berkeley’s Center for Responsible Decentralized Intelligence. The simulated world requires me to complete a series of tasks, each one unlocking a door. My goal is to move from virtual room to virtual room by solving puzzles that involve creative thinking, memory skills, and physical movements, all naturally integrated into the experience.

Louis Rosenberg inside a Virtual Escape Room created by researchers at UC Berkeley (2022)

I am proud to say I made it out of the virtual labyrinth and back to reality. Of course, this was created by a research lab, so you might expect the experience was more than it seems. And you’d be right — it was designed to demonstrate the significant privacy concerns in the metaverse. It turns out, while I was solving the puzzles, moving from room to room, the researchers were using my actions and reactions to determine a wide range of information about me. I’m talking about deeply personal data that any third party could have ascertained from my participation in a simple virtual application.

As someone who’s been involved in virtual and augmented reality for decades, and who’s been warning about the hidden dangers for years, you’d think the data collected would have not surprised me. But you’d be wrong. It’s one thing to warn about the risks in the abstract — it’s something else to experience the privacy issues firsthand. It was quite shocking, actually.

That said, let’s get into the personal data they were able to glean from my short experience in the escape room. First, they were able to triangulate my location. As described in a recent paper about this research, metaverse applications generally ping multiple servers which enabled the researchers to quickly predict my location using a process called multilateration. Even if I had been using a VPN to hide my IP address, this technique would still have found where I was. This isn’t shocking, as most people expect their location is known when they connect online, but it is a privacy concern none the less.

Going deeper, the researchers were able to use my interactions in the escape room to predict my height, the length of my arms (wingspan), my handedness, my age, my gender, and basic parameters about my physical fitness level, including how low I could crouch down and how quickly I could react to stimuli. They were also able to determine my visual acuity, whether or not I was colorblind, the size of the room that I was interacting from, and basic assessments about my cognitive acuity. The researchers could have even predicted whether I had certain disabilities.

It’s important to point out that the researchers used standard hardware and software to implement this series of tests, emulating the capabilities that a typical application developer could employ when building a virtual experience in the metaverse. It’s also important to point out that consumers currently have no way to defend against this — there is no “privacy mode” in the metaverse that conceals this information and protects the user against this type of evaluation.

Well, there wasn’t any protection until the Berkeley researchers began building one — a software tool they call “MetaGuard” that can be installed on standard VR systems. As described in a recent paper from lead researchers Vivek Nair and Gonzalo Garrido of U.C. Berkeley, the tool can mask many of the parameters that were used to profile my physical characteristics in the metaverse. It works by cleverly injecting randomized offsets into the data-stream, hiding physical parameters such as my height, wingspan, and physical mobility, which otherwise could be used to predict age, gender, and health characteristics.

MetaGuard Image from Nair and Garrido

The free software tool also enables users to mask their handedness, the frequency range of their voice, their physical fitness level and conceal their geospatial location by disrupting triangulation techniques. Of course, MetaGuard is just a first step in helping users protect their privacy in immersive worlds, but it’s an important demonstration, showing that consumer-level defenses could easily be deployed.

At the same time, policymakers should consider protecting basic Immersive Rights for users around the globe, guarding against invasive tracking and profiling. For example, Meta recently announced that their next VR headset will include face and eye tracking. While these new capabilities are likely to unlock very useful features in the metaverse, for example enabling avatars to express more realistic facial expressions, the same data could also be used to track and profile user emotions.

This could enable platforms to build predictive models that anticipate how individual users will react to a wide range of circumstances, enabling adaptive advertisements that are optimized for persuasion. Such ads in the metaverse has been theoretical, but just this month ROBLOX (which boasts over 50 million daily active users, nearly all of them kids) announced they will begin “immersive advertising” in 2023. If a company focused on kids is headed in this direction, we can guess that most major platforms will follow unless policymakers put restrictions in place.

Without regulation, we need to worry that immersive advertising could cross the line from marketing to manipulation. This could be used to push products or services through predatory means, or worse it could drive misinformation more efficiently than any current technologies. As I discussed with POLITICO last week, an unregulated metaverse could become the most dangerous tool of persuasion humanity has ever created.

Don’t get me wrong — I firmly believe the metaverse has the potential to be a very positive technology for humanity. That’s why I have been pushing for immersive worlds for over 30 years. At the same time, the extensive data collected by virtual and augmented platforms is a major concern and requires a wide range of solutions, from protective tools like MetaGuard to thoughtful and meaningful metaverse policy and regulation.

— Note: this article originally appeared in VentureBeat.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Cardano's ADA Hits Highest Level Since May 2022 as Bitcoin Nears $100K and Capital Rotates into Alternative Cryptocurrencies

    Cardano's ADA has reached its highest level since May 2022, with evidence of significant participation from large traders in the on-chain activity. As Bitcoin approaches the $100,000 mark for the first time, capital is shifting towards alternative cryptocurrencies, generating excitement in the wider crypto market. Additionally, Bitcoin has broken a new record above $98,000, and there are reports that former US President Donald Trump is considering appointing a "Crypto Czar" and a crypto lawyer for SEC Chair. BlackRock's IBIT options launch has also contributed to Bitcoin's new ATH.

  • Matrixport: It is recommended that institutional investors allocate both Bitcoin and gold

    On November 22, Matrixport's latest weekly report shows that the progress of the fifth Bitcoin bull market coincides with its prediction for July 2023. The report predicts that Bitcoin will reach $125,000 in December 2024, and with Bitcoin approaching the $100,000 mark, this prediction becomes more credible.

  • How Crypto Could Help Open-Source AI Reach Its Potential

    The impact of artificial intelligence (AI) is being felt across various sectors, including drug discovery, workforce productivity, and personalized content on streaming platforms like Netflix. Experts predict that the AI industry will grow by 40% annually and reach a trillion-dollar market by 2030, potentially transforming industries on an unprecedented scale. The use of cryptocurrency could play a crucial role in enabling open-source AI to overcome current limitations and reach its full potential.

  • ECB board member Patsalides warns Trump's tariff plan could lead to stagflation in Europe

    Christodoulos Patsalides, a member of the European Central Bank's board, warns that if US President-elect Donald Trump follows through on his threatened trade tariffs, the European economy could ultimately fall into stagflation. "Trade tensions are escalating," said the Cyprus Central Bank governor on Thursday in Nicosia. "If trade restrictions become a reality, the outcome could be inflation, economic recession, or worse, stagflation." He said that although there is room for further lowering of borrowing costs, it should be done "at a stable pace and magnitude."

  • Scam Sniffer: Crypto-Malware "Meeten" Renamed to "Meetio", Reminding Community to Be Vigilant

    Scam Sniffer posted on X platform, stating that the crypto conference malware "Meeten" has been renamed to "Meetio". The community is warned to be vigilant, as the renamed application is just a "disguise" and still poses a security threat.

  • Bankless Co-founder: The market has entered the beginning of the second half of the crypto bull market

    Ryan Sean Adams, co-founder of Bankless, posted on X platform stating that the current market has entered the beginning stage of the second half of the crypto bull market.

  • Elon Musk appointed by Trump to lead advisory board on government efficiency and restructuring

    President-elect Donald Trump has appointed Elon Musk and Ramaswamy to lead an advisory board called the "Department of Government Efficiency." The board aims to reduce government bureaucracy, cut wasteful spending, and restructure federal agencies. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene will chair a House subcommittee on "DOGE" to recommend executive actions to reduce waste and provide savings for taxpayers. Musk and Ramaswamy are reportedly creating a smartphone app for Americans to file taxes for free, causing shares of tax filing services H&R Block and Intuit to drop. However, the commission has received criticism from Senator Elizabeth Warren.

  • Curve: Market leverage demand surged after Trump's election, and protocol revenue grew rapidly

    On November 21st, Curve Finance stated that the crypto industry has experienced a large-scale increase after Trump recently won the US election. Key stocks such as MSTR and COIN have been reevaluated, and Bitcoin has approached the $100,000 mark. The demand for leverage has led to an increase in DAO's weekly income, rising from an average of $268,000 before Trump took office to $581,000 in the past week. Currently, the annual income allocated to veCRV holders is approximately $31 million, not including income from participating in voting incentives. As of today, including voting incentive bonuses, DAO has accumulated $554 million.

  • Paypal: There is a problem with the system at present, which may affect multiple products

     Paypal: Currently experiencing system issues that may affect multiple products; Merchants may be facing a higher number of errors.

  • Web3's Great Gambit: Incentives for the Almost Impossible

    “When you’re young, you look at television and think, There’s a conspiracy. The networks have conspired to dumb us down. But when you get a little older, you realize that’s not true. The networks are in business to give people exactly what they want. That’s a far more depressing thought. Conspiracy is optimistic! You can shoot the bastards! We can have a revolution! But the networks are really in business to give people what they want. It’s the truth.” - Steve Jobs