Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

FTX and the Case for Web3 YIMBYism

From coindesk By Alex Tapscott

(White House, modified by CoinDesk)

Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of FTX, was the latest in a long and storied line of personalities whose compelling elevator pitches papered over their poor management practices.

Though it purported to raze the walled gardens of traditional finance, FTX was probably just garden variety fraud. In the aftermath of the exchange’s collapse, Congressman Patrick McHenry (R-NC) urged his colleagues “to separate out the bad actions of an individual from the good created by an industry and innovation.”

Rep. Tom Emmer (R-MN) called it “a failure of centralization, a failure of business ethics, and a crime. It is not a failure of technology.” As the trial unfolds and as more evidence comes to light, these early insights appear prescient and true.

Web3’s Chernobyl

Still, is it possible the collapse of FTX derails Web3's growth?

Throughout history, promising innovations and even groundbreaking technologies have been sidelined by disasters, which change public perception. Chernobyl put a halt to new nuclear power projects which could have otherwise supplied the planet with abundant green energy. When the South Sea Company’s bubble burst in 1720, critics blamed its joint-stock structure as a high-risk legal invention; and governments banned their formation for a century.

Stung by those calamitous failures, people became NIMBYists [not in my backyard], choosing to halt all innovation rather than learn from their mistakes. These examples teach us that early failures and the response from governments can bend the arcs of technological adoption and diffusion, shortening their development horizons by years —or extending them by decades.

Is FTX Web3's Chernobyl?

FTX punctuated an era. It’s time to forge anew

“Some people in crypto have acted for too long as if Web3 was a given, as if it would follow the same trajectory as the Web in the 1990s,” Albert Wenger of Union Square Ventures told me in an interview for my new book “Web3: Charting the Internet’s Next Economic and Cultural Frontier.” “There was no sales tax on the iternet. There was the safe harbor of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, the safe harbor of the Communication Decency Act, that famous Section 230. We had all these regulatory tailwinds.”

By contrast, “Web3 has regulatory headwinds everywhere in the world, especially in the United States,” he said.

Wenger’s prescription for scaling Web3 starts with regulatory clarity about what’s a security and what’s not. The uncertainty around how to classify tokens has pushed innovation offshore.

FTX operated offshore in part because of a lack of clarity in the U.S. By pushing capital formation offshore the U.S. risks losing oversight and transparency into their doings (and in this case wrongdoings).Nuclear power is a useful analogy here too. Where would you rather develop nuclear power and harness its awesome power in America – with strong laws and oversight – or offshore and risk meltdown?

A growing chorus of academics, economists and businesspeople agree that we need a workable long-term framework. In a 2023 speech, Hester Peirce of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) observed: “If we continued with our regulation-by-enforcement approach at our current pace, we would approach 400 years before we got through the tokens that are allegedly securities.”

Enterprises, financial institutions and other large players will also be reluctant to invest long-term until there are clear rules of the road.

Strong policies can amplify the positive effects of clear regulations.

In ”The Innovators,” Walter Isaacson reminds us that “innovation occurs when ripe seeds fall on fertile ground.” Like the earth beneath our feet, we stand on stratums of innovation with markers of their age. Government can help to sow the seeds of innovation too and the solution can be bipartisan.

See also: Sam Bankman-Fried Needs Better Answers on the Stand | Opinion

Legislators can unleash the power of the private sector by turning barriers to entering traditional financial markets into guardrails for innovation. Rather than reshoring only legacy businesses of legacy industries, the Biden administration can also reshore Web3 firms and create good paying jobs in the U.S. in next era of the internet.

Reject Web3 NIMBYism and build it here in America. That’s pushing Web3 forward responsibly.

Note: The views expressed in this column are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of CoinDesk, Inc. or its owners and affiliates.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • The JuCoin ecological project JuChain has been launched on the main network, and the public chain co construction summit will be held. The ecological debut protocol is Butterfly

    Cointime News:JuCoin's self-developed public chain JuChain has been launched on the main network. The JuChain Public Chain Co construction Summit initiated by JuCoin will be held on May 15, 2025 in Bangkok, Thailand. The conference will release the first ecological agreement--

  • BTC breaks through $96,000

    the market shows that BTC has broken through $96,000 and is now trading at $96,014.98, with a 24-hour increase of 1.15%. The market fluctuates greatly, so please manage your risks well.

  • Martin Young ·

    North Carolina House passes state crypto investment bill

    North Carolina’s House passed a bill to allow the state treasurer to invest government funds in approved cryptocurrencies with a 71 to 44 vote.

  • Ciaran Lyons ·

    Galaxy Digital plans Nasdaq listing as crypto stocks post strong rebound

    Galaxy Digital’s Mike Novogratz says the Nasdaq listing will provide an easier gateway for exposure to the crypto and AI ecosystem.

  • Martin Young ·

    US crypto groups urge SEC for clarity on staking

    A group of nearly 30 crypto advocate groups has asked the SEC to provide legal clarity on crypto staking, arguing that it's not an investment activity.

  • JuCoin CEO: UX design in the encryption industry needs to pay attention to user emotional details to enhance user experience

    Cointime News: JuCoin CEO Sammi Li delivered a keynote speech at the TOKEN2049 conference, analyzing the current challenges in user experience (UX) design in the cryptocurrency industry. Sammi Li believes that the existing encryption product experience fails to effectively empathize with users, often leading to usage anxiety, which hinders the large-scale adoption of Web3. Combining her rich experience in the luxury goods industry, she emphasizes that building trust relies on paying attention to user emotions and critical moments of interaction, and constructing it through details rather than simply technical presentations. JuCoin is applying these user centered design principles to its Web3 ecosystem construction, aiming to lower user barriers and enhance user experience by optimizing JuChain and related product designs. It calls on the encryption industry to think together and place user experience at a more core position.

  • Xiongan New Area: Combining blockchain with digital RMB to launch "Digital Currency Loan" product, with payment amount of nearly 100 million yuan

    On January 11th, according to the Xiong'an Public Account, the digital RMB pilot in Xiong'an New Area has achieved new results. The first digital RMB tax payment transaction in the financial field has been completed, and self-service tax terminals have been developed. The "blockchain + digital RMB" technology is applied to government procurement management, increasing the proportion of advance payment and landing multiple applications to solve corporate problems. In 2024, the People's Bank of China Xiong'an New Area Branch, together with the Xiong'an New Area Reform and Development Bureau, will launch the "Implementation Plan for the Deepening of the Pilot Work of Digital RMB in the Rongdong Area", to enhance public awareness. By combining blockchain with digital RMB, the "digital currency loan" product will be launched, with a payment amount of nearly 100 million yuan.

  • Fardi Wang, Chairman of NEXUS 2140: AI•Web3•Ecom Global Expo, Made Appearance at Meta Crypto Oasis 2025 in Dubai

    Fardi Wang, Chairman of NEXUS 2140: AI•Web3•Ecom Global Expo, recently appeared at the Meta Crypto Oasis 2025 in Dubai, joining global Web3 leaders such as Justin Sun (Founder of TRON) and Chris (Co-founder of Sonic) to discuss the future of the industry. As the first cross-industry event integrating AI, Web3, and E-commerce, NEXUS 2140 is accelerating its international expansion through Fardi Wang’s active participation. At the summit, Fardi Wang emphasized that the integration of virtual and real-world assets is the key breakthrough for the Web3 ecosystem. He mentioned: “NEXUS 2140 is leveraging Korea’s policies, technological strengths, and ecosystem advantages to build a global industrial hub.” His insights received strong recognition from attendees, and the Dubai visit further amplified the international influence of the event, injecting new momentum into global digital economy collaboration.

  • Binance Wallet’s New TGE B² Network is Now Available for Investment

    according to official page data, Binance Wallet's new TGE B² Network is now open for investment, with an end time of 18:00 (UTC+8). The participation threshold for this TGE is that Alpha points must reach 82 points.

  • The price of ALPACA perpetual contract on Binance platform rose by more than 25% in the past 5 minutes

    the current price of ALPACA perpetual contract on the Binance platform has risen by over 25% in the past 5 minutes, now falling back to $1.3683. At the same time, the spot price of ALPACA is $1.22, showing a significant price difference.