Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

Coinbase Takes Aim at CFTC's Definition of 'Gaming' in Proposed Prediction Market Rules

Edited by Omkar Godbole.

Coinbase argues the definition is vague, and urges the CFTC to make determinations on a contract-by-contract basis rather than broad categorization

  • Coinbase responded to the CFTC's proposed rules regarding prediction markets, taking aim at how the CFTC proposes to define 'gaming'.
  • Coinbase would like the CFTC to regulate prediction markets on a contract-by-contract basis instead of using broad categories or definitions.

Proposed rules by the Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regarding prediction markets should be withdrawn because they exceed the commission's statutory authority and ignore the positive impact of prediction markets on the economy, Nasdaq-listed crypto exchange Coinbase wrote Thursday in a letter to Commissioners.

"We firmly believe that this all-or-nothing approach to the treatment of event contracts is not consistent with the promotion of responsible innovation and growth in regulated, transparent markets with appropriate safeguards to protect market integrity and protect customers," Coinbase's Chief Legal Officer, Paul Grewal, wrote in the letter.

In May, the CFTC published a proposal on event contracts (prediction markets) that defined "gaming" as betting on outcomes of political contests, awards, or athletic events. This proposal had the support of three Democratic commissioners, CoinDesk reported at the time, who cited concerns over market integrity and the agency's role.

In Thursday's letter, Coinbase wrote that it objects to the CFTC's broad definition of "gaming," arguing that it unfairly restricts valuable event contracts by categorically banning them without considering their individual public interest merits.

"If adopted, the rule would capture contracts as "gaming" that by any common understanding are not, in fact, gaming," Coinbase wrote, arguing that this is inconsistent with "legislative history related to gaming, neither of which suggest that gaming should extend beyond sporting events".

Coinbase gave one use case for prediction markets for sporting events: a vendor hedging the costs of printing t-shirts in anticipation of a team winning a championship by taking a position in favor of that team's loss.

The exchange complained in the letter that the Commission equates speculation with gaming but fails to distinguish between market speculation and actual gambling in its proposal.

"Few would agree that elections or professional awards such as Nobel Prizes or Academy Awards are granted through a process that should generally qualify as games, yet these are the examples presented as constituting such a definition," Coinbase continued.

The proposal would also ban contracts on war, terrorism, and assassination.

Polymarket offers several contracts about geopolitical outcomes that would fit into this category, such as one that asks bettors if Iran will launch military action against Israel by next week in response to Israel's assassination of Hamas' leader in Tehran.

These may be useful for forecasting world events, and Coinbase argued that the CFTC is overlooking what it calls the significant benefits of prediction markets. Coinbase cites research showing that prediction markets can efficiently aggregate information and outperform traditional forecasting methods.

Instead, Coinbase proposes that the CFTC withdraw the broad, categorical ban on event contracts and continue evaluating them on a contract-by-contract basis, considering the public interest merit of each prediction market category.

"We urge the CFTC to withdraw this proposal and work alongside academic, industry, and policy stakeholders to develop a more balanced approach that promotes innovation while protecting the public interest," Coinbase's Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal posted on X.

Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Decentralized computing power monetization network NodeGo completes $8 million in financing, led by Hash Capital

    decentralized computing power monetization network NodeGo announced the completion of an $8 million financing round, led by Hash Capital. The new funds will be used to build the network, allowing users and businesses to contribute to AI tasks by completing space and other calculations, while also allowing participants to earn rewards.

  • DeFi investment platform Prodigy.Fi completes $5 million seed round of financing, led by Quantstamp and Republic

    DeFi investment platform Prodigy.Fi announced the completion of a $5 million seed round of funding, with Quantstamp and Republic leading the investment, and Arbelos Markets, RSK Capital, and Samara Alpha Management participating. The new funds are intended to support the platform's ability to buy or sell packaged cryptocurrencies such as Wrapped Ethereum (WETH) based on Berachain.

  • Solana restaking protocol Fragmetric completes $7 million seed round

     Solana's re-staking protocol, Fragmetric, has completed a $7 million seed round of financing. Finality Capital Partners and Hashed jointly led the investment, with Hypersphere, Presto Labs, Bitscale Capital, Halo Capital, and Flowdesk also participating. The new funds aim to enhance the security and economic growth of the Solana ecosystem by establishing a re-staking ecosystem through standardized LRT and community contributions.

  • Lightchain AI announces testnet launch and completes $15 million in financing

    blockchain project Lightchain AI has announced the official launch of its testnet and has completed a $15 million financing round. The project's main technological innovations include the Proof of Intelligence (PoI) consensus mechanism and the AI Virtual Machine (AIVM). The PoI consensus mechanism is achieved by rewarding nodes to solve AI computing problems, while the AIVM provides developers with a toolkit to build AI applications on the blockchain. The project is currently in the final round of presale, and the funds raised will be used for technology development, infrastructure expansion, and talent recruitment. Lightchain AI plans to launch its mainnet in 2025 and will focus on developing enterprise-level decentralized AI solutions in the future.

  • Over 64.5404 million USD was liquidated in the past hour, mainly due to long orders

    According to data, in the past hour, the total liquidation amount of the entire network reached 64.5404 million US dollars, of which the liquidation amount of long positions was about 63.1007 million US dollars, and the liquidation amount of short positions was about 2.2016 million US dollars.

  • The State Council Tariff Commission: Additional tariffs will be imposed on some imported goods originating from the United States

    The State Council Tariff Commission issued a notice: with the approval of the State Council, tariffs will be imposed on some imported goods originating in the United States from February 10, 2025. A 15% tariff will be imposed on coal and liquefied natural gas, and a 10% tariff will be imposed on crude oil, agricultural machinery, large-displacement cars, and pickups. (Jinshi)

  • Japanese listed company Remixpoint increased its holdings by 30.83 BTC, bringing its total Bitcoin holdings to 509.33

    Japanese listed company Remixpoint announced on February 3 that it had released a "Notice of Additional Purchase of Cryptocurrency" on January 30, 2025, and passed a resolution to purchase a total of 2 billion yen (approximately $12.89 million) worth of cryptocurrency at a board meeting held on the same day. Based on the resolution, the company completed the purchase of the first 500 million yen (approximately $3.22 million) worth of cryptocurrency on January 31, 2025, including the addition of 30.83 BTC, bringing the company's total Bitcoin holdings to 509.33.

  • US spot Ethereum ETF had a net inflow of $83.54 million yesterday

    According to  TraderT monitoring shows that the net inflow of US spot Ethereum ETF was 83.54 million US dollars yesterday.

  • Coinbase Chief Legal Officer: US SEC blocks Coinbase’s request to disclose Gary Gensler’s communication documents

    Paul Grewal.eth, the Chief Legal Officer of Coinbase, wrote on the X platform that the issues of Chevron and Binance's secondary sales have been clarified, but in Coinbase's lawsuit, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has prevented Coinbase from requesting the disclosure of Gary Gensler's communication documents. In March 2021, Gary Gensler told the U.S. Congress that the SEC lacked regulatory authority over digital asset exchanges, confirming the long-held belief among market participants that digital asset trading on these exchanges is not within the jurisdiction of securities law. Coinbase has requested that Gary Gensler provide documents related to these communications because they are related to how the SEC's enforcement actions violate the due process requirements of the Constitution, but the SEC and Gary Gensler are trying to prevent the disclosure of these documents.

  • The listing of spot ETFs has caused Coinbase's Bitcoin reserves to decline rapidly since February

    CryptoQuant disclosed on X platform that the listing of Bitcoin spot ETF caused the Bitcoin reserves of Coinbase exchange to rapidly decline since February. Data shows that on February 18, 2024, Coinbase's Bitcoin reserves were about 1,044,997 BTC, but now this indicator has decreased to 878,000 BTC, a decrease of about 167,000 BTC.